Lisa Brinkhaus came back to her room on a November morning holding a tube of lotion she had just won at Bingocize, a game that mixes bingo with stretching. She is 67, a retired veterinary technician, and a fall at home once left her unable to walk. Now, she says, she can cover the length of a football field several times a day. Her nursing home in New Prague, Minnesota, helped get her there.
As first reported by The Minnesota Star Tribune, stories like hers are getting harder to find across the state. A newspaper analysis found Minnesota is losing nursing homes, and the quality of care at many of those still open has slipped.
Minnesota had 376 nursing homes in 2019. Today it has fewer than 340. Over the same stretch, the Star Tribune found, the number of homes carrying a one-star overall rating, the lowest grade on the federal government’s five-star scale, nearly doubled, from 34 to 64.
The timing is bad. The oldest baby boomers are turning 80, and the generation’s need for long-term care is expected to outgrow what the state can provide.
The paper noted that the rating system grades on a curve and has been adjusted over the years. Elder-care advocates said that does not explain away the drop. Kristine Sundberg of Elder Voice Advocates, a Minnesota nonprofit that works to end abuse and neglect of vulnerable adults, put it bluntly. Some of the staffing problems are real, she said. Some of it is greed.
Some of the closures read like warnings. The Terrace at Crystal, which ranked among the state’s homes caring for the most medically complex residents, shut down this summer after its owner could not make payroll. Its 58 residents had to move. Bay View Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Red Wing, which cared for people with brain injuries and residents on ventilators, closed after its owner stopped paying workers, even after lawmakers approved special payments to keep it open.
Both were for-profit businesses. The Star Tribune reported that for-profit owners now control about 30 percent of Minnesota’s nursing homes but half of the homes with one-star ratings. Researchers caution that this does not prove for-profit ownership causes the problems. Those owners may simply be running the homes no one else will take.
Staffing is strained everywhere. Eighty-four Minnesota nursing homes had to replace at least half of their nursing staff in the past year, according to the paper, and federal data showed fewer nurses and aides per resident at for-profit homes than at nonprofit ones.
The industry points to money. The Long-Term Care Imperative, which represents two nursing home trade groups, said state payment rates have not kept up with wages. It is pushing a plan to guarantee quality care within 45 minutes of every Minnesotan’s home.
Monarch Healthcare Management, based in Eagan, is the largest for-profit owner in the state, with 44 homes acquired over about a decade. Only two of them carry five-star ratings in the latest rankings. Sixteen carry one star.
Chief Executive Marc Halpert told the paper that Monarch took over many of those homes when they were already struggling and at risk of closing, and that turning them around takes time. The company spent $650,000 renovating Mala Strana, the New Prague home where Brinkhaus lives, and its rating climbed from two stars to four.
Star ratings are a blunt tool. But the pieces underneath them, staff turnover, short shifts and owners who cannot pay the bills, are the same pieces we see in nearly every serious bedsore case.
A home that loses half of its nurses in a year loses the people who know which resident needs turning every two hours, whose heels are already red, and who has stopped eating. New staff can learn. But while they do, the gaps show up on residents’ skin first.
Closures carry their own risk. Moving a frail resident on short notice means a new building, new caregivers and a new care plan, often written in a hurry. That is exactly when a wound can be missed.
Look at a facility’s ratings over several years, not just this month. Sundberg told the paper that occasional problems are expected. “It’s the year after year ones that worry us the most,” she said. Ask who owns the home and whether that has changed recently. Ask how long the nurses and aides on your loved one’s unit have worked there.
If a home is closing or changing hands, ask for a copy of your loved one’s care plan and recent skin assessments before the move, and check their skin yourself in the first days at the new place.
If your loved one developed a bedsore or was harmed in a nursing home, Bedsore.Law can help you understand what happened and whether it should have been prevented. Call 844-407-6737 or visit bedsore.law/contact for a free, confidential consultation.